Hi dear Blu-ray lovers. Sorry I'm french and I don't speak german
(it's been a while... I have learned basis at the middle school, sorry).
I discovered and started to read this thread few days ago after a "googlize" session . We experience the same problem in France for almotst 10 years.
There r multiple causes about these defective BD discs, at least in our country, the first cause is an industrial incident with a french based disc factory named QOL (Quantum Optical Laboratories), so many french Blu-ray disc titles
(from Gaumont, Pathé, EuropaCorp, Wild Side, etc...) are defective from 2008 to 2015. Please avoid them, especially in the second-hand market. Maybe you've heard about it ? Let me know.
An another cause could be
(it's almost sure) a bad aging
(because of poor materials or corrupted resin used during the manufacturing process) even with a the good storage conditions wich Blu-ray lovers are aware with.
Sometimes the hardware could be implicated with a curious behavior, because the OPU is aged and the lens would be dusted or worned out. So, the large amount, the high density of data stored on those discs needs a perfect tracking and a flawless correction.
But there's still something wrong with these BD discs and I know myself more than good the problem because I have a BD collection about 6K movies, concerts; documentaries etc... and I get almost 200 defective BDs. I stopped testing few years ago and drastically limited my BD purchases (HD & 4K). I prefer to buy in the second-hand stores where I can see discs and read IFPI data, before paying. It allow me to avoid many problems now.
So, I decided in 2016 with friends I met on different french forums, to stard a website about this problem and above all to identify potentially defective BDs.
"Blu-ray défectueux" means in german "Fehlerhafte Blu-ray"
Regards.